THE AUCTION HOUSE

Commodities and their delay

any auctioneer / any level / stacks, the queue and the payout / alone

I sold two stacks of Copper Bar one afternoon and waited at the mailbox for the gold. It started to rain. After an hour the gold came, and by then I'd also had time to sell a knife, which paid me while I was still standing there. Nixie Brassbottom heard the story in Booty Bay. She said anyone who waits at a mailbox has too little to do, and went back to her ledger.

Why it pays

Forever's auction house treats anything that stacks in your bags as a commodity, as far as the travellers can tell, so cloth, bars, herbs and dust all count. A commodity doesn't sell as separate auctions. Every listing of one item goes into one queue, a buyer says how many he wants, and the house sells him the cheapest. The buyer never sees who he buys from. Weapons, armour and anything else that doesn't stack still sell one auction at a time.

Three things follow, and each one is worth money. You post the whole pile at once, and one post costs one deposit, so a stack of cheap dust costs the same silver as a single one. You never need to undercut by a copper. One traveller found that among listings at the same price the newest one sells first, so matching the cheapest price puts you at the front of the line, and going a copper under only costs you a copper on every item. And the gold comes at different speeds. In the beta, commodity gold took about an hour to arrive, and a single Big Bronze Knife paid out in about two minutes.

the whole pileone post, one depositone queuematch the cheapestabout an hourthen the gold
a single weapon paid out in two minutes

How

  1. Put everything you have of one item into a single post.
  2. Look at the cheapest price in the queue and match it. Go lower only when you want your whole pile gone before everybody else at that price.
  3. Sell, then go and do something useful. Commodity gold arrives about an hour later.
  4. When you need gold back quickly to buy the next lot, sell single items. A weapon or a piece of armour pays in minutes.
  5. Buying works the same way backwards. Ask for the number you need and look at the total before you click.

TODAY ON THE MARKET

Copper Bar: price unknown

Linen Cloth: price unknown

Big Bronze Knife: price unknown

What can go wrong

The hour and the two minutes come from one traveller in September, early in the beta, and he wondered himself whether the fast payout was a mistake. The order of the queue comes from the same man. The market is large and quick, too. The export counts thousands of Copper Bars sold a day on a single market, so the cheapest price you matched at noon may be gone by the time you've walked to the auctioneer.

BASTIAN'S VERDICT Match the cheapest price, post the whole pile at once and come back for the gold in an hour.

The rumours on this page

[Half right] Commodity purchases take the cheapest listings first, however many items the buyer wants, and nobody can see who the seller is.

The Forever client's commodity buy list shows a price and a quantity and no seller, and the buyer only chooses how many (UI source, build 70450). Which listings the house fills first we could not see.

Gillee, 2026-09-29, at 4:28 watch

[Heard, not checked] The deposit is one silver for the entire post, regardless of stack size.

Gillee, 2026-09-29, at 2:18 watch

The Lazy Goldmaker, 2026-10-13, at 0:55 watch

Sean Cool (seancool_com), 2026-10-20, at 33:10 watch

Deviant, 2026-10-21, at 3:44 watch

Gillee, 2026-10-22, at 15:44 watch

[Heard, not checked] The commodity queue is last in first out: an item posted at 1 silver 23 copper goes to the front of the queue, so posting one copper lower gains nothing.

Gillee, 2026-09-29, at 3:53 watch

[Heard, not checked] Gold from a sold commoditized item takes about an hour to come through, while a sold non-commodity item such as a big bronze knife is expected to pay out in about two minutes.

Gillee, 2026-09-29, at 8:41 watch

[Heard, not checked] A stack of an item in your bags is probably considered a commodity now.

Gillee, 2026-09-29, at 0:23 watch

On this page

  • Copper Bar
  • Big Bronze Knife